Maximum Power Transfer Theorem Proof and Example

Maximum Power Transfer Theorem state that maximum power will transfer from source to load if and only if the load resistance is equal to source internal resistance. The theorem was first time presented by Moritz von Jacobi in 1840.

Maximum power transfer theorem is a tool for designing rather than circuit analysis. The theorem is purely about the transfer of power not efficiency. In early stages, the theorem was misunderstood as the efficiency of circuit notably by James Prescott Joules. According to the assumption, an electric system can’t be more than 50% efficient. But in the 1880’s, Thomas Edison proved the assumption wrong and practically achieved nearly 90% efficiency of an electric circuit.

Maximum power transfer Theorem

Power Transfer OR efficiency ?

Efficiency is something different than power dissipation in load. Efficiency is the ratio of power dissipated in load and power provided by the source. The efficiency will always be increased by decreasing in source internal resistance.

In the Thevenin Theorem and Norton Theorem, we observed that any linear circuit can be reduced to a single source and single resistor expect load resistor. In case of the more complex circuit, the load resistor should be equal to Thevenin’s resistor after applying Thevenin’s theorem to the circuit. The Thévenin’s resistor act as source internal resistor.

Explanation with Example :

Suppose the following complex circuit reduced to Thevenin’s resistor and Thevenin’s voltage source. Where Rth and Vth are fixed and we want to change the load resistor R such that load gets maximum power dissipation.

Maximum Power Transfer Theorem

Solution:

Numerical Explanation :

I want some numerical elaboration of the above example. I am going to vary the load resistor value from 1 to 8 in eight steps and we would plot the result on a graph. Here is the value of the different value of the load resistor, the corresponding efficiency (on left), and dissipated power (on right).

Maximum Power Transfer Theorem
Maximum-Power-Transfer

From the above data and then graph it is easily visible that the load dissipates maximum power i.e. 56.3 watts when the load resistor is the same as an internal resistor (Thévenin’s resistance in this case) i.e. 4 Ohms in this case. In contrast, note another graph, given on the left, that efficiency is continuously improving as we increase the load resistor.

Maximum power Transfer Theorem Proof :

Resistive Circuit:

Now we should proceed with the analytical proof of the above claim, as it is the local maxima of the graph if you are familiar with calculus. Suppose the following diagram, where voltage V and internal resistance of source Ri are fixed and load resistance R is variable. We are going to find the load resistance such that maximum power is dissipated in load. The current flowing in the circuit is:

$I=\frac{V}{R_{i}+R}$

Power dissipated in the load resistor R, is P$_{L}$, calculate as follow:

$P_{L}=I^{2}R=(\frac{V}{R_{i}+R})^{2} R$

$P_{L}=\frac{V^{2}}{\frac{R_{i}^{2}}{R}+2R_{i}+R} $

To find the maximum power dissipation in load, we have to minimize the denominator term in the above equation, which is a quadratic equation in variable R and contain only one global minima. If you are familiar with calculus, to compute that minima, we have to take the derivative with the respect that variable and put it equal to zero.

$\frac{d}{dR}(\frac{R_{i}^{2}}{R}+2R_{i}+R)=0 $

$-\frac{R_{i}^{2}}{R}+1=0 $

$\frac{R_{i}^{2}}{R^{2}}=1\\ OR\\ \frac{R_{i}}{R}= \pm 1$

$R_{i}=\pm R$

We know that practical it is not possible to have a resistor of negative values, so the above equation becomes:

$R_{i}=R$

Hence we have proved the load resistor R should be same as source internal resistor Ri to have maximum power dissipation in load.

Reactive Circuit:

Practically, every load has some non-linearity and contain some components of capacitance and/or inductance, which lead to a reactive component in the circuit. The theorem is also applicable in that case. According to the theorem, maximum power will transfer to the load if and only if the load impedance is a complex conjugate of the internal impedance of the source.

In radio transmission system, it is the core objective to match the impedance of radio receiver to the complex conjugate of a transmission line or antenna, so, that the receiver set (which act as load) get maximum power at a specific frequency.

Maximum Power Transfer Theorem

Suppose we have a fix source voltage V and the fixed internal impedance of source as Zi and variable load impedance as ZL. The current flowing through them will be I:

$\vert I\vert =\frac{\vert V\vert }{\vert Z_{i}+Z_{L}\vert }$

The power only dissipates in resistor only rather than capacitor and inductor, so the power dissipated in load will be:

$P_{L}=I_{rms}^{2} R_{L}=\frac{1}{2}I^{2} R_{L}=\frac{1}{2}(\frac{\vert V\vert }{\vert Z_{i}+Z_{L}\vert })^{2}R_{L}$

$P_{L}=\frac{1}{2}(\frac{\vert V\vert }{\vert R_{i}+R_{L}\vert ^{2}+ \vert X_{i}+X_{L}\vert ^{2}})^{2}R_{L} \quad \dots (1)$

For power to be maximum, the denominator part of the above equation should be minimum i.e. near zero.

$X_{L}-X_{i}=0 OR X_{i}=-X_{L} \quad \dots (2)$

Plug to the equation to (2) to equation (1), so we get the equation below:

$P_{L}=\frac{1}{2}(\frac{\vert V\vert }{\vert R_{i}+R_{L}\vert })^{2} R_{L}$

It remains to solve the equations above for R$_{L}$ so that we get maximum power dissipated in load resistor. Now the equation is exactly same as we started in purely resistive loads, and the solution is exactly the same way.

$R_{L}= R_{i}$

Finally, load impedance Z$_{L}$ should be:

$Z_{L}=R_{L}+jX_{L}=R_{i}-jX_{i}$

The above discussion has proved that the load impedance ZL should be the conjugate of the source internal Impedance Zi to have maximum power delivered to the load.

Sending
User Review
3 (1 vote)

Leave a Reply